Chapter 9 - The Defense Falters

|
Sterling approached the witness box with the careful, calculated steps of a man walking through a minefield. Cross-examining a child victim was always risky; push too hard, and the jury would instantly turn against him.
"Hello, Sofia," Sterling said, forcing a tight, artificial smile. "I just have a few questions for you."
Sofia clutched the rabbit tighter but did not look away.
"You mentioned that Veronica disciplined you," Sterling began casually. "But isn't it true that you were often disobedient? You threw tantrums, refused to eat your vegetables, and broke expensive items around the house?"
"I broke a vase by accident," Sofia said, her voice small but steady. "I didn't mean to."
"But you did break it," Sterling pressed. "And Mrs. Vance, acting as a maternal figure in your father's frequent absence, felt the need to correct that behavior, didn't she?"
"She locked me in the dark," Sofia replied, her voice gaining a fraction of volume.
"Isn't it true," Sterling pivoted quickly, recognizing the danger, "that your father was the one who was truly absent? Mrs. Vance was the only one providing structure. Perhaps you resented her because she wasn't your real mother?"
"Objection! Badgering and argumentative," Sarah Vance called out sharply.
"Sustained. Move on, Mr. Sterling," the judge warned severely.
Sterling sighed, pacing back to his table to retrieve a document.
"Sofia, you claim Veronica burned a photograph of your mother. But we have no evidence of this. Isn't it possible you lost the photo and are simply blaming her because you are angry?"
Sofia looked at Sterling, then at Veronica.
"She burned it in the fireplace in the study," Sofia said clearly. "She told me that ashes belong with ashes. She said my mother was dead, and if I wasn't careful, I would be forgotten too."
Two jurors physically recoiled. One woman covered her mouth.
Sterling realized instantly he had pushed too far. He had opened a door that allowed the pure, unadulterated cruelty of his client to spill out into the open.
"No further questions, Your Honor," Sterling muttered, practically retreating to his seat.
Sofia stepped down from the stand. As she walked back to Alexander, he stood up and offered his hand. She took it, squeezing his fingers tightly.
May you like
"You did perfectly," Alexander whispered.
"I told the truth," she said simply.